Oh, this is wonderful. I love the picture you've created of Toby here. This fic made me smile and sigh and go "Awwwww" for poor Toby.

“No, that’s okay,” he replies, figuring the least he can give her (or, well, the most) is the opportunity to listen to Dido in the presence of another human being without being mocked for it.

This line was my favorite, I think. I absolutely love it. The anti-Jim sentiment without actually saying it out loud.

Thanks for sharing!